Wednesday, December 19, 2007

MTA Board Meeting - December 12th

At the December 12th meeting of the MTA Board, NHP Trustee L. Montreuil made the following presentation regarding the LIRR Mainline Corridor Improvement Project (which includes plans for three at grade crossing elimination projects in New Hyde Park):

http://www.mta.info/mta/webcasts/player.htm?id=071212_0930_LIRR_300.wmv&mv=wmp-hires&src=archive

It is important to note that from our inception as of April 2007, Save Our Village's official position has always favored the at-grade crossing elimination projects in New Hyde Park. However, we vehemently oppose the current MTA proposals which jeopardize our economic stability, environment, and suburban quality of life. Once again, Save Our Village insists that the MTA-LIRR and all federal, state and local elected representatives of the mainline communities
  1. explore alternatives which promote safety, reduce roadway congestion, and preserve our suburban lifestyle;
  2. promote the best plan that inflicts the least collateral damage to family homes and properties, regardless of its cost
  3. negotiate respectfully with all citizens who are directly and indirectly impacted so that they do not suffer unfair economic hardship and can remain residents within their chosen community
SAVE OUR VILLAGE NEW HYDE PARK ASSOCIATION, INC. WISHES TO POSITIVELY ACKNOWLEDGE THE NHP VILLAGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES FOR ELOQUENTLY REPRESENTING THE COLLECTIVE VOICE OF OUR GROWING LIST OF SUPPORTERS!

PLEASE READ THE IMPORTANT INFORMATION BELOW TO LEARN MORE ABOUT THE PROCESS AND THE PLAYERS WHO HAVE THE POWER TO PROTECT AND PRESERVE OUR HOMETOWN COMMUNITY!

Friday, December 7, 2007

"In a world of universal deceit, telling the truth will be a revolutionary act." George Orwell, 1984

MTA Capital Program Review Board

Background:
Every five years, the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) must submit a capital spending program for the next five years. This fiscal system was established in the early 1980's to insure that New York's subways and commuter railroads (which were nearly collapsed in the late 1970's from decades of deferred maintenance) received adequate capital investment. This process was successful; thus, New York's rail transit systems presently function with reasonable reliability.

The VOTE and the VETO
  • Under NYS Law, an MTA Capital Program must be unanimously approved by a four member board known as the Capital Program Review Board. Approval of a capital program is presumed unless, within 90 days, a member of this board vetoes it. The members of this board are appointed by the Governor of New York, NYS Senate Majority Leader, the NYS Speaker of the Assembly, and the Mayor of New York City.
  • As a member of the Capital Program Review Board (CPRB), each member is responsible for reviewing, monitoring, and approving the MTA's proposed multi-billion dollar five year spending program. Since all capital programs must be unanimously approved, each member's power to veto enables him/her to pass and/or reject any proposal(s) presented to the CPRB.
  • On matters related to commuter railroads, Ms. Astrid Glynn, Senator Dean Skelos, and Assemblyman Keith Wright are the members of the CPRB who must vote unanimously to pass commuter railroad-related transportation proposals. A veto by any one of these members can stop a proposed project as well as the allocation of monies to fund this project. Additionally, any individual on the CPRB can approve the project with stipulations added to an agreement. Mr. Doctoroff is the 4th member of the CPRB who votes on issues related only to NYC Transit proposals.
  • As a result of Senator Skelos' (9th Senate District, Nassau County) leadership on the MTA Capital Program Review Board, the MTA is presently advancing one of its most comprehensive rail systems expansion programs in over 50 years! In 1998, Senator Dean Skelos was appointed to the CPRB by Governor Pataki and since then, he has served as the NYS Senate's representative on this four-member board.
MTA Capital Program Review Board: Organization

The following elected representatives appoint the members of the CPRB:
  1. NYS Governor Eliot Spitzer
  2. NYS Senator Joseph Bruno, Majority Leader of the Senate, 43rd Senate District
  3. NYS Assemblyman Sheldon Silver, Speaker of the Assembly, 64th Assembly District
  4. Mr. Michael Bloomberg, Mayor of the City of New York
The following appointees are members of the MTA's Capital Program Review Board:
  1. Senator Dean Skelos, 9th Senate District (Nassau County)
  2. Assemblyman Keith Wright, 70th Assembly District
  3. Ms. Astrid Glynn, NYS Department of Transportation, Commissioner
  4. Mr. Daniel L. Doctoroff, Deputy Mayor of Economic Development, NYC

(click on image to enlarge view)

Federal Funding for Transportation Projects

Timeline:
After the MTA and the LIRR produce the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS), citizens can attend public hearings to voice their comments about the project. These public hearings usually take place approximately three months after the DEIS is issued. Thereafter, the MTA and the LIRR must address the concerns raised by citizens during the public comment period in their Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) to satisfy federal guidelines. Afterwards, the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) may allocate money approved by Congress through the Transportation, Housing and Urban Development Appropriations Bill.
  1. Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS)
  2. Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)
Federal Procedures and Guidelines
  • Annually, the ENTIRE Congress votes on approximately 11 Appropriations bills. One of these bills is called "The Transportation, Housing and Urban Development Bill." If this bill is approved by Congress, the funds are allocated to the Department of Transportation which then allocates a portion of this funding to ALL the individual states. This funding is used for roads, highways, bridges, tunnels, airports and railroads.
  • After an Appropriations Bill is approved by Congress, no member of Congress can add amendments to the bill. All amendments or stipulations must be added to the bill before the vote.
  • The MTA/LIRR may choose not to use federal money to fund its projects. Instead, they may choose to fund an entire project with money allocated to them through the NYS Department of Transportation.
Thus, the following representatives are the key players in the process of approving the "LIRR Mainline Corridor Improvement Project":

1. NYS Governor Eliot Spitzer
2. NYS Senator Joseph Bruno, NYS Senate Majority Leader - 43rd Senate District
3. NYS Assemblyman Sheldon Silver, Speaker of the Assembly, 64th Assembly District
4. NYS Senator Dean Skelos, 9th Senate District and member of CPRB
5. Ms. Astrid Glynn, Commissioner, NYS Dept. of Transportation and member of CPRB
6. Assemblyman Keith Wright, 70th Assembly District and member of CPRB

The information presented above is provided by Save Our Village New Hyde Park Association, Inc. for the exclusive review of our supporters. Any use and/or reproduction of this or any other material on this blog site must be approved by the Board of Save Our Village New Hyde Park Association, Inc.

Friday, November 30, 2007

News Alert!

Recently, Brookhaven National Laboratory announced to elected representatives in Nassau, Suffolk, Queens and the Bronx that it will soon begin to ship 4,000 cubic feet of radioactive soil on railway cars to a disposal site out of New York State. The soil, which was excavated from a former waste disposal area at the Upton facility in Suffolk County, has been contaminated with cesium as a result of previous operations at the lab. It will be loaded onto several rail cars which will carry it to a containment facility in Utah. Freight trains on Long Island are operated by New York and Atlantic Railways on tracks owned by the Long Island Railroad.

It is important to note that the proposed Long Island Truck – Rail Inter Modal Facility (LITRIM) in Suffolk County and the LIRR Mainline Corridor Improvement Project are two of several railway expansion proposals in our region which can enable significantly more freight railway traffic to pass along the mainline corridor. Increased freight rail traffic can have a direct and negative impact on the quality of life of those citizens who reside in such “mainline” communities as Bellerose, Floral Park, New Hyde Park, Garden City Park, Garden City, Carle Place, Mineola, Westbury and Hicksville.

As SOV New Hyde Park continues to explore this development, we strongly encourage residents to share their concerns with those who have direct influence on matters which can potentially affect the health, safety and general welfare of our neighborhood – contact your local, state and federal representatives and let your voice be heard!

Friday, November 23, 2007

URGENT NEWS BULLETIN!

Save Our Village recently noted several developments announced at a LIRR Meeting held on November 14th. For your convenience, we have linked a video of this meeting below:
http://www.mta.info/mta/webcasts/player.htm?id=071114_0930_lirr_300.wmv&mv=wmp-hires&src=archive

It is important to note that from the beginning SOV's official position has ALWAYS favored the at-grade crossing elimination projects in New Hyde Park. We, however, remain staunchly opposed to:
  • the original and current proposals recommended by the LIRR to eliminate these at-grade crossings
  • the use of eminent domain to eliminate these at-grade crossings
To reinforce our original and ONLY position on this issue, Save Our Village recognizes the environmental and safety issues which prompt the need for the At-Grade Crossing Eliminations Projects in New Hyde Park. We do believe that there are other ways to achieve these goals. SOV strongly recommends that the MTA-LIRR and all federal, state and local elected representatives who have influence regarding this issue:
  1. vigorously explore other viable alternative plans which will promote greater safety and the reduction of roadway congestion;
  2. responsibly endorse the best plans that inflict the least collateral damage to family homes and properties;
  3. respectfully negotiate with all citizens who are directly and indirectly impacted so that they do not suffer unfair economic hardship and can remain residents within their chosen community.
Once again, Save our Village supports the vision of at-grade crossing eliminations in New Hyde Park. However, we will settle for nothing but the best plans to achieve this goal...regardless of the cost.

Friday, November 16, 2007

SENATOR JOHNSON ADVOCATES FOR MAINLINE COMMUNITIES

This week Mrs. Helena Williams announced that the public hearings regarding The Third Track Project will likely take place in Spring, 2008. Upon hearing this announcement, the officers of SOV took immediate note of Ms. Williams' comments and responded to countless calls about her message. Additionally, we are happy to report that Senator Craig Johnson, once again, remembered our plight and immediately advocated for citizens' direct communication with Mrs. Williams regarding the "pair of options" which she referred to in her announcement. We invite all our supporters and interested citizens to read Senator Johnson's letter below:

November 15, 2007

Helena Williams
President, Long Island Rail Road
Jamaica Station
Jamaica, NY 11435-4380

Dear Ms. Williams:

I read with great interest an article in Newsday today regarding your plans for the Third Track. As you know from meetings I have had with you since you became LIRR President, I am vehemently opposed to the Third Track project until the MTA / LIRR presents a clear and honest plan that meets with the approval of local residents, civic leaders and government officials. One aspect of the article which stood out to me the most was your quote – “A pair of options for the Long Island Rail Road's plan to establish a third track along a 10-mile stretch of its Main Line will be unveiled at a series of public hearings this spring.” This is welcome news and I appreciate your willingness to allow the residents who could be most adversely affected by the plan to let their voices be heard.

To that end, I respectfully request that you hold a series of public meetings in close proximity to the following communities in my Senate district - Bellerose, Floral Park, New Hyde Park, Garden City Park, Carle Place, Mineola, Westbury and Hicksville. The residents of these communities will bear the brunt of any plans you put forward and therefore deserve as many chances as possible to speak their minds.

I also request that you give local civic groups an opportunity to host meetings for their members with representatives from the MTA / LIRR in attendance. There are a number of local groups in my district who have taken a keen interest in the Third Track project and one of their biggest complaints, which I share, has been the lack of direct communication from the MTA / LIRR to the community about the true nature of the project. I would be happy to help set these meetings up and I offer my assistance in any way that will help bring about a new, open dialog between the MTA / LIRR and the residents who have made their homes and raised their families along the main line corridor.

Thank you for taking the time to consider my request. Should you have any further questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Sincerely,

Craig M. Johnson, Senator, 7th District

The officers of Save Our Village eagerly await to hear of a response to Senator Johnson's plea. We believe that Mrs. Williams will quickly learn firsthand that the officers and supporters of Save Our Village are civic-minded and hardworking homeowners and taxpayers who are ready and willing to work cooperatively with her to address the issues brought about by the Third Track Project and the three At-Grade Crossings Elimination Projects proposed in New Hyde Park.

Senator Johnson continues to demonstrate to us that he remains a strong advocate for the working citizens of all the mainline communities throughout the 7th district. We applaud his proactive participation in encouraging direct communication between Mrs. Williams and the "mainline" citizens who remain concerned about future stability of their neighborhoods.

Friday, November 9, 2007

News Update

  • SOV New Hyde Park Association wishes to extend its thanks to the New Hyde Park Illustrated News for its comprehensive coverage of our recent community presentation, "Citizens vs. the Threat of Eminent Domain". We strongly encourage all supporters and interested citizens to purchase the Nov. 9th edition of the paper and read it carefully. This article can also be found on the Anton News website at http://www.antonnews.com/illustratednews/
  • New Hyde Park-Garden City Park residents are also invited to view Cablevision's Channel 115 every Thursday evening from 8-10PM for a program entitled "NHP-GCP Issues and Topics." In addition to other important issues, SOV's recent community presentation, "Citizens vs. the Threat of Eminent Domain," will be shown in its entirety on Thursday, Nov. 15th and Nov 22nd. This public access program is produced and directed by an independent New Hyde Park citizen.
  • News coverage and information about SOV's community presentation can also be read in the Nov. 2nd edition of the New Hyde Park Herald Courier.
SOV New Hyde Park Association wishes to express our sincerest appreciation to our local newspapers and public access channels for helping us in our mission to provide our neighbors with accurate information about issues which effect our suburban quality of life.

Sunday, November 4, 2007

"Don't Shoot the Messenger!"

On October 29th, 2007 Save Our Village hosted an educational seminar entitled, “Citizens vs. the Threat of Eminent Domain” as it relates to the impact of current proposals set forth in the MTA-LIRR-NYSDOT’s “LIRR Mainline Corridor Improvement Project”. Historically, in cases that involve eminent domain, homeowners whose properties have been identified as “condemned” are at risk for serious economic hardship since the proposed compensation is often significantly less than if these residents sold their homes privately. Thus, our New Hyde Park neighbors, the "human costs" of these proposals, will be forced out of our community. It is also important to note that the resulting loss of tax base will burden the remaining taxpayers who reside in our community. Additionally, while our school district could be compensated if it lost its own property to such projects, it cannot be compensated for the loss of tax base that results from the condemnation and elimination of residential homes and businesses in the area. Thus, the remaining taxpayers, all the citizens who reside the "11040" area, will be forced to pick up the costs which result from condemnation in the form of higher school taxes and higher property taxes.

The first keynote speaker, Mr. A. Thomas Levin, Esq., who was honored with the "2006 Public Interest Attorney of the Year" Award by the Touro College’s Jacob D. Fuchsberg Law Center located in Huntington, is a member of the law firm of Meyer, Suozzi, English & Klein P.C., and Chair of the firm's Municipal Law, Land Use and Environmental Compliance practice. He concentrates his practice in the fields of local government law, land use regulation, and commercial litigation, representing both private and public sector clients. He serves or has served as special counsel to numerous villages, local governments and agencies. Mr. Levin is also the current President of the National Caucus of State Bar Associations and Past-President of the New York State Bar Association.

The second keynote speaker, Mr. Edward Gutleber, Esq. is an expert in the area of eminent domain law and he represents property owners in appropriation damage claims. Prior to joining the law firm of Meyer, Suozzi, English & Klein P.C., he served as Deputy Chief of the Municipal Services Bureau, Real Estate and Condemnation Unit, of the Suffolk County Attorney’s Office and as a principal litigation attorney in county condemnation and real property tax cases. Mr. Gutleber was a member of the NYS Bar Association House of Delegates from 1994-2002 and elected as a Fellow of the NY Bar Foundation in 1999, and the recipient of the Suffolk County Bar Association’s Award of Recognition in 1990 and 1995.

The evening was devoted to learning the theory and practical applications of eminent domain law. The harsh economic realities that will be imposed on our community as a result of the proposed condemnation and elimination of homes and small businesses in New Hyde Park quickly became evident on the faces of those present in the audience. While this project will impact other communities along the mainline, New Hyde Park faces significant and serious challenges in the near future. It is important to note that both Mr. Levin and Mr. Gutleber agree, “The courts in the end do not second guess the wisdom or the merits of the decision…that is a political decision...Projects more often get defeated politically than in the courts." Save Our Village extends our appreciation to both these experts for their time, their consideration, and their dedication in helping our neighbors who will potentially face serious hardship in the near future as well as helping our community, in general, which faces an uncertain economic future as a result of these current proposals.

Our special guest, Senator Craig Johnson of the 7th Senate District addressed the audience regarding the local and regional impact of the LIRR Project and his views on the issues. It is important to note that Senator Johnson reiterated that he is against the Third Track Project “and will continue to be against the Third Track Project until the MTA presents a clear plan to the community that is approved – and this is most critical – that it is approved by you the residents, by your local civic organizations and by the local officials."

Save Our Village respectfully asserts that the “human costs” of the MTA-LIRR-NYSDOT's current plans, coupled with the serious negative economic implications for the remaining taxpayers in our community, require a commitment to careful deliberation by our elected representatives and direct consultation with the voters and taxpayers who live along the mainline. SOV New Hyde Park encourages those who propose and/or endorse railroad modification: (1) to learn more about the consequent economic and environmental effects it imposes on the mainline corridor communities, (2) to advocate for the deliberate and vigorous exploration of viable alternative proposals that reduce roadway congestion and promote safety, and (3) to responsibly endorse the best plan that imposes the least collateral damage to family homes and properties, school districts, small businesses, and the environment in our immediate area – regardless of its cost.

The homeowners and taxpayers of New Hyde Park will settle for nothing less than the best plan!!